Evaluating novel building products through a building design-oriented LCA approach: Example of VIPs in terrace applications
Loading...
Date
2024-06-12
Authors
Božiček, David
Košir, Mitja
Zach, Jiří
Novák, Vítězslav
Peterková, Jitka
Bubeník, Jan
Lešek, Anja
Jordan, Sabina
Malovrh Rebec, Katja
0000-0002-0426-8317Advisor
Referee
Mark
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
IOP Publishing Ltd
Altmetrics
Abstract
The construction industry is considered conservative in adopting new products/technologies, and environmental characteristics are one of the most important features of novel solutions. In this context, our study aims to present a building design-oriented assessment of a novel building product by extending the functional unit scope and involving multiple realistic building design scenarios. The task will be performed using the example of vacuum insulation panels (VIPs), a superinsulation product that can be used in various building applications. The study will focus on terrace insulation applications, where VIPs are an attractive solution for building designers due to the possibility of barrier-free floor design. However, they lack environmental evaluation. METHOD: A life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis is performed on two hypothetical buildings located in Ljubljana (Slovenia) for the cradle-to-gate and operational energy life cycle stages (A1-A3 + B6 according to EN 15978). A whole-year dynamic thermal response simulation was executed using the Design Builder software. Five barrier-free terrace design scenarios that influence the embodied and operational carbon footprint (while maintaining the functional and architectural integrity of the building design) were examined. RESULTS: The study showed that although EPS insulation showed a smaller embodied carbon footprint on the product level, the building level analysis showed that using VIPs in terrace applications leads to favourable or comparable environmental impact. CONCLUSIONS: Building products can be evaluated on three functional unit levels: product, application and building. By extending the boundaries from the product/application level to the entire building level, the study provides an example of a building design-oriented approach to LCA. The complexity increases by upgrading the functional unit scope to the building level, while the results become more case-specific and less general. Ideally, a novel building product should show environmental superiority on all three levels. However, as there are almost countless design possibilities in buildings, environmental superiority (or inferiority) on the product level does not necessarily indicate superiority (or inferiority) on the building level.
Description
Keywords
Citation
IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. 2024, vol. 1363, issue 1, p. 1-18.
Document type
Peer-reviewed
Document version
Published version
Date of access to the full text
Language of document
en