OLIVOVÁ, B. Ogródki Działkowe: z minulosti do budoucna [online]. Brno: Vysoké učení technické v Brně. Fakulta architektury. 2025.
Barbora Olivová's thesis presents a very interesting research and design project that significantly addresses an important topic related to urbanism, sustainable development, and the social responsibility of architecture. The project fully achieves the goals outlined in the thesis, presenting a concept for a small-scale residential estate integrated with new allotment gardens, creating a functional public space aimed at supporting the local community. The project stands out due to its exceptional aesthetics, both in terms of architectural concept and graphic design. Her student presentation is well thought out and professionally prepared, combining modern visualization techniques with a clear, coherent narrative. The visualizations, boards, and booklet are of high quality and precision, effectively illustrating the design intentions. Barbora's skills in computer graphics and visual presentation are of a very high standard, making the work appealing from an artistic perspective as well. The clarity of the presented concepts and ideas contributes to the ease of understanding and interpretation of the project, which deserves particular recognition. Barbora Olivova was very active during all the academic year, including involvement in study trips and preparation of the Student Quarter: Plac Defilad exhibition in Warsaw. Her exhibited project was met with a very positive response from the audience. The theoretical part of the thesis is solid and well-documented. She presents the urban context in a reliable manner, taking into account both social and ecological aspects. The concept of integrating allotment gardens with a modern residential estate is well-founded, with ideological underpinnings supported by the analysis of the role of allotment gardens in cities and their contribution to sustainable development. The thesis addresses the protection of green areas from commercial development and the need for public spaces to be integrated with different user groups, which strengthens the work and fully responds to the current challenges of contemporary urbanism. Although the project is very well thought out with excellent theoretical foundations, there are some reservations regarding the design process. Upon analyzing the entire work, it is noticeable that there is a tendency to delay design decisions, which may lead to stagnation in the search for alternative solutions. The lack of experimentation with different urban and design layouts in the early stages of the project results in a somewhat predictable solution. While the final concept is functional and aligns with the initial assumptions, the lack of greater innovation in terms of spatial organization or architectural form may limit the project's potential in the context of modern urban trends. It would have been beneficial to take more design risks, particularly in experimenting with different spatial layouts or technological solutions that could introduce a more pioneering approach to the topic. Barbora Olivová's thesis is a project that deserves a high grade, particularly in terms of its artistic and graphic qualities, as well as its solid theoretical analysis. Despite some minor reservations regarding the design process, the overall project is a coherent and functional proposal that addresses significant challenges in contemporary urban architecture. This work serves as an excellent example of a conscious approach to urbanism, taking into account both social and ecological needs, and demonstrates the potential of a young designer to create spaces that not only meet the current needs of residents but also add value to the urban landscape.
| Kritérium | Známka | Body | Slovní hodnocení |
|---|---|---|---|
| Přístup studenta ke zpracování | B | Barbora Olivová's thesis presents a very interesting research and design project that significantly addresses an important topic related to urbanism, sustainable development, and the social responsibility of architecture. The project fully achieves the goals outlined in the thesis, presenting a concept for a small-scale residential estate integrated with new allotment gardens, creating a functional public space aimed at supporting the local community. The project stands out due to its aesthetics, both in terms of architectural concept and graphic design. Student presentation is well thought out and professionally prepared, combining modern visualization techniques with a clear, coherent narrative. The clarity of the presented concepts and ideas contributes to the ease of understanding and interpretation of the project, which deserves particular recognition. Barbora Olivova was very active during all the academic year, including involvement in study trips and preparation of the Student Quarter: Plac Defilad exhibition in Warsaw. Her exhibited project was met with a very positive response from the audience. The theoretical part of the thesis is solid and well-documented. She presents the urban context in a reliable manner, taking into account both social and ecological aspects. The concept of integrating allotment gardens with a modern residential estate is well-founded, with ideological underpinnings supported by the analysis of the role of allotment gardens in cities and their contribution to sustainable development. Although the project is very well thought out with excellent theoretical foundations, there are some reservations regarding the design process. Upon analyzing the entire work, it is noticeable that there is a tendency to delay design decisions, which may lead to stagnation in the search for alternative solutions. While the final concept is functional and aligns with the initial assumptions, the lack of greater innovation in terms of spatial organization or architectural form may limit the project's potential in the context of modern urban trends. Barbora Olivová's thesis is a project that deserves a high grade, particularly in terms of its artistic and graphic qualities, as well as its solid theoretical analysis. Despite some minor reservations regarding the design process, the overall project is a coherent and functional proposal that addresses significant challenges in contemporary urban architecture. This work serves as an excellent example of a conscious approach to urbanism, taking into account both social and ecological needs, and demonstrates the potential of a young designer to create spaces that not only meet the current needs of residents but also add value to the urban landscape. |
Verbal evaluation of work: Barbora Olivová's thesis addresses a precisely defined problem, providing comprehensive explanations, well analyzing the urban context and the existing situation with spatial planning documentation, reviewing the history, and an extensive architectural proposal. The thesis is well-prepared and structured, representing subsequent stages of problem elaboration. The author relies on the historical context and explains the importance of preserving the green zone in the central part of the city. Barbora explains that it is important for this part of the city not only to preserve the greenery, leaving the linear park as a green corridor to maintain the interconnection of the city's green areas, but also to add a socially important function - social housing adapted for active urban gardening. The design area includes public facilities and personal plots with houses, in which a workshop room connected to an individual plot for active economic activity occupies a separate important place. The individual plots are formed by streets and driveways that consider the local landscape and facilitate the free drainage of rainwater from the complex. Working in the right direction, the author nevertheless rather timidly proposes introducing modern ecological solutions into the traditional layout of personal plots. I would advise emphasizing the green corridor with a boulevard between the northern part of the planning site and the linear park, as well as boldly bringing it to the southern part, proposing a green pedestrian bridge over the main road and justifying the need to extend it to the outskirts of the eastern part of the city. To reduce the width of the roadway, it is necessary to streamline traffic on the project site: offer one-way traffic on some streets and turning areas in dead ends, and ensure a minimum passage width for fire trucks. Consider dedicated routes with a preference for bicycle traffic to give it an advantage over cars. The author also proposes the establishment of a waste composting area, which I would suggest locating farther from residential buildings and closer to the public area. This approach would help prevent the spread of unpleasant odors into residential areas and serve as a model for other city residents. The master plan proposal includes several triangular pocket parks, and I recommend adding an example of visualization or further describing the function of these green "triangles." Are there places for recreation, bicycle parking, or playgrounds? I would also recommend detailing the layout of the park in the northern part of the site and calculating the number of residents who will live in this area - these indicators will be key to determining the social value of this project. The project addresses a very painful topic of our time - along with urbanization, we are also witnessing the opposite phenomenon of suburbanization, when people flee from the noise of the city to quiet green suburbs, because the city ceases to provide a full life for its residents, offering more and more small apartments and not reducing the possibility of a good rest near their own homes. The author proposes to move away from the concept of concentrating as many residents as possible in the central part of the city and give its residents additional opportunities for recreation and social adaptation. The project deserves a grade of A – Exellent.
eVSKP id 167706